Wednesday 23 September 2009

Colston's School again

Today we see that the application is recommended for approval, including the removal of the tree. Yes, they now intend to replace it, but it's taken a real effort to get even this far. Come and lobby the council next week.

The Poplars at the back of the school are also proposed for the axe - which has certainly upset the neighbours. Here's a letter to the Head from a resident of St Andrews Road:

"Dear Mrs Jones,

You have submitted a planning application to enlarge the
school grounds. That in itself is a laudable enterprise, in
that no doubt it will enhance facilities for your students
and lead to better and more congenial learning environment.
However, part of your plans are to cut down the row of nine
black poplar trees that have been growing for decades along
the eastern boundary of your school grounds. That is neither
laudable, nor 'green'(the web site states you are 'Going
Green'), nor necessary.

Your school web site advertises that you 'specialise in
languages'. Perhaps your German department and the students
studying that language and culture might care to read and
discuss the following poem by Bertolt Brecht (I898-I956),
written in 1950 on the occasion of a poplar tree found still
standing after most other trees in war-torn and ruined
Berlin had been hacked down for fire wood during the
freezing winter of 1946/7:

Die Pappel vom Karlsplatz - Das freundliche Grün

Eine Pappel steht am Karlsplatz
Mitten in der Trümmerstadt Berlin
Und wenn Leute gehn übern Karlsplatz
Sehen sie ihr freundlich Grün.
In dem Winter sechsundvierzig
Fror'n die Menschen, und das Holz war rar
Und es fielen da viele Bäume
Und es wurd ihr letztes Jahr.
Doch die Pappel dort am Karlsplatz
Zeigt uns heute noch ihr grünes Blatt:
Seid bedankt, Anwohner vom Karlsplatz
Daß man sie noch immer hat!

And for the benefit of those not knowledgable of German a
rather loose translation:

A poplar stands on Charles Square
In the middle of ruinous Berlin
And when people go across Charles Square
They see her friendly green.
In the winter of forty-six
The people froze, and the wood was rare
And many trees were felled
And it was her last year.
But the poplar there on Charles Square
Still today shows us her leafy green:
Thank you, residents of Charles Square
That we still have her with us.

I hope you will pass this on to your relevant teaching
staff and I would welcome your feedback concerning the
outcome of this educational piece of unfortunately rather
topical literary analysis. I would be especially interested
in what reactions your students had to the proposed plans to
remove 'their' poplars.

Yours sincerely..."



Tuesday 22 September 2009

Doomed?

Skanska is at it again. Not content with taking out a number of important trees at Cotham School, the day before Good Friday when no enforcement action could be taken, Skanska now expects to do the same again in Cheltenham Road.


Skanska appear determined to chainsaw an important local tree as part of its planning application for new buildings at Colston’s School.

Please let us know if you can help to save this important tree which is to be removed without any meaningful consultation.


The tree is an important street tree outside the Colston’s school site and is part of the Cheltenham Road avenue of plane trees. During the consultation process Skanska stated categorically, “plane tree on pavement to be retained”. However, by the time the application was submitted Skanska submitted misleading documents which show images with the tree retained and casting dappled shade on the new building. Yet the small print states that the tree is to be removed. Then on 3rd September a flurry of new documents appeared on the planning web site confirming finally, that the tree would go and offering the small guesture of a replacement planting.

We need your help:
If you objected in writing to the planning proposal you can speak at the Planning Committee meeting on 30th September.
We can offer information as to how to contribute to this debate.
Any other activities and press work to highlight the fate of the tree
www.BristolStreetTrees.org contact us: Quercus (at) BristolStreetTrees (dot) org

Background notes:
The application Colston Girls School Cheltenham Road Bristol BS6 5RD was published on the Bristol City Council Web site on 22 May. Google Application 09/01456/FB or use the web link below

A flurry of new documents were posted on the web site on 3rd September, many weeks after the planning application was put in. Such an approach prevents any comment on the new documents as the comment period has expired.

Of particular interested is the arboricultural report, last on the list of associated documents http://e2edocs.bristol-city.gov.uk/WAM/findCaseFile.do?appName=planning&appNumber=09/01456/FB

The tree is listed in the arboricultural report as grade A2, which means that it is an important tree with an expected lifespan of more than 40 years which will make a substantial contribution in the future and should be retained. (According to BS 5837 Trees in relation to Construction)

The importance of the tree was raised by the Bristol Urban Design Forum (letter 10th December 2008 p21 in the “Statement of Community Involvement) which stated that, “we were delighted to hear that every effort will be made to keep the tree”.

The importance of the tree was also highlighted in at least three successive meetings with the Montpelier Conservation Group (also in the “Statement of Community Involvement).

Excerpts of Skanska’s own planning document are included as a PDF (Colstons.pdf). The tree in question is highlighted with red circles which we have added. Only by reading the small print would one have any inclination that the tree was to be removed.

More information on the Cotham Trees is available on the blog site of local councilor Neil Harrison http://cotham.blogspot.com/2009/04/trees-at-cotham-school.html and the Bristol Evening Post http://www.thisisbristol.co.uk/homepage/Inquiry-calls-Bristol-trees-felled/article-1209480-detail/article.html